16 Nightmarish US Urban Legends You Shouldn’t Read Before Bed

We are all intrigued by morbid curiosity yet slightly fearful that there might be some truth to it. Urban legends are fascinating tales that float around in our collective consciousness, often blurring the lines between fact and fiction.

We all know of the popular ones, like the Loch Ness monster or Bigfoot. But plenty of lesser-known urban legends in the US are equally bizarre and intriguing.

Heard from spooky stories whispered around campfires to wild claims made over social media, these legends scare your kids and keep us on the edge of our seats. Here are 16 such US urban legends that you probably didn’t know existed.

1. The Slender Man

• Originated: Internet forums, 2009

To summarize Slender Man, he’s a tall, faceless figure lurking in the shadows, stalking and abducting children. This modern-day boogeyman originated from a Photoshop contest but quickly took on a life of its own, spawning countless stories, games, and even movies.

Slender Man has been blamed for creepy ordeals, with some people even claiming to have seen him in real life. If you ever get lost in the woods, just hope you don’t see a faceless silhouette in the distance.

2. The Mothman of West Virginia

• Origin: Sightings began in Point Pleasant in the mid-1960s.

The Mothman, a large-winged creature with glowing red eyes, first flapped its way into public consciousness in the mid-1960s, terrorizing the town of Point Pleasant.

Some people claim that seeing the Mothman is a surefire sign that disaster is around the corner. In fact, the infamous Silver Bridge collapse was preceded by numerous Mothman sightings.

Despite its terrifying appearance, the Mothman has become a local celebrity, complete with his own statue and annual festival.

3. The Jersey Devil

• Originated: Pine Barrens, New Jersey, early 1700s

The Jersey Devil is so famous that it even lent its name to the New Jersey Devils hockey team!

This kangaroo-like creature with bat wings and a horse’s head has been haunting the Pine Barrens since the early 1700s. According to folklore, it was the 13th child of Mother Leeds, born with hooves and a hunger for mischief.

Over the centuries, there have been hundreds of sightings.

4. The Vanishing Hitchhiker

• Originated: Various locations, widespread

Typically, the story of the Vanishing Hitchhiker involves a driver picking up a hitchhiker only to have them vanish without a trace. The only thing often left behind is something personal like a jacket or a chilling warning.

While this legend has countless variations, it usually ends with the driver visiting the hitchhiker’s last known address, only to discover they’ve been dead for years.

5. The Goatman of Maryland

• Originated: Prince George’s County, Maryland, 1957

The Goatman of Maryland is a half-man, half-goat hybrid who supposedly stalks the woods of Prince George’s County, wielding an ax and terrorizing teenagers.

Tales of the Goatman date back to the 1950s, with some claiming he’s the result of a mad scientist’s experiment gone wrong. Others prefer a more supernatural explanation, insisting he’s a demon or cryptid. The Goatman has even been blamed for mysterious disappearances and deaths.

6. The Bunny Man

• Originated: Fairfax County, Virginia, 1970

Virginia’s Bunny Man proves that you should never judge a book by its cover, especially when it involves a man in a bunny suit wielding an ax.

In 1970, reports surfaced of a man dressed as a rabbit vandalizing property and terrorizing locals. According to the tales, the Bunny Man haunts a specific bridge in Fairfax County.

It’s such a bizarrely specific story that it’s become a local favorite, inspiring everything from horror movies to Halloween costumes.

7. Cropsey

• Originated: Staten Island, New York, 1970s

Cropsey is Staten Island’s boogeyman. This urban legend describes a deranged killer who supposedly lurked in the ruins of the Willowbrook State School.

What makes Cropsey particularly chilling is that it’s based on a real person, Andre Rand, who was convicted of several child abductions. Over time, the line between fact and fiction blurred, creating a monstrous figure that haunts local lore.

8. The Bell Witch

• Originated: Adams, Tennessee, early 1800s

Before there was “The Blair Witch Project,” there was the Bell Witch of Adams, Tennessee. This classic haunt tale dates back to the early 1800s when the Bell family reported being tormented by an unseen force.

According to the legend, the spirit, known as Kate, could speak, move objects, and even physically attack people. The Bells’ plight drew the attention of neighbors and even General Andrew Jackson, who supposedly had a run-in with the witch.

The story has been passed down through generations, bolstered by historical records. Today, the Bell Witch Cave is a popular tourist attraction.

9. The Melon Heads of Ohio

• Originated: Kirtland, Ohio, 1970s

The Melon Heads are one of Ohio’s creepiest urban legends. These small humanoid creatures reportedly have large, bulbous heads and live in the woods around Kirtland.

According to local lore, they were once children who suffered horrific experiments at the hands of a deranged doctor. Over the years, they escaped and now lurk in the forests, scaring off anyone who gets too close.

Stories of the Melon Heads have been circulating since the 1970s, with numerous sightings and encounters.

10. The Black Eyed Children

• Originated: Abilene, Texas, 1996

Based on a spooky tale that originated in Texas in the late ’90s, the Black-Eyed Children are said to be demonic entities with completely black eyes and a hypnotic power over their victims.

According to the legend, these children will appear at your doorstep asking for help or requesting to be let in. Anyone who falls under the spell of their all-black gaze is doomed to bad luck, illness, or worse.

11. The Lizard Man of Scape Ore Swamp

• Originated: Lee County, South Carolina, 1988

In the swamps of South Carolina lurks an unbelievable creature: the Lizard Man of Scape Ore Swamp, first spotted in 1988 by a terrified teenager whose car had been attacked. The Lizard Man is described as being seven feet tall, covered in green scales, and sporting a pair of impressive claws.

Since then, waves of witnesses claim to have seen this swamp stalker skulking around the murky waters.

Regardless of his origins, the Lizard Man has become a local legend, inspiring everything from tourist merchandise to a Lizard Man Festival.

12. The Charman

• Originated: Ojai, California, mid-20th century

Most people who take a day trip to California’s Ojai, will never hear of the fiery phantom, the Charman. He is said to be the ghost of a man who was severely burned in a fire and now haunts the area.

According to the legend, the Charman can be seen wandering the woods, his charred skin and burnt clothing terrifying passersby. He’s also known for chasing after cars and scaring unsuspecting drivers.

13. The Lady in White

• Originated: Various locations, widespread

Many legends and haunted places across the United States mention a “Lady in White.” Usually, she’s described as a mournful woman dressed in a flowing white gown, often seen along lonely roads or near bodies of water.

The specifics of her tale vary, but she’s usually connected to a tragic love story, a lost child, or some other heartbreaking event. Many towns have their own version of the Lady in White, making her one of the most ubiquitous urban legends.

14. The Green-Clawed Beast

• Originated: Ohio River, Indiana, 1955

In 1955, an aquatic anomaly allegedly attacked a woman swimming in the Ohio River, leaving claw marks on her leg and a lifelong fear of water. Described as a green, scaly creature with webbed hands, the beast supposedly grabbed her and tried to drag her underwater.

Though she managed to escape, the legend of the Green-Clawed Beast was born. Fact or fiction, many monster hunters have searched this river to find the elusive creature.

15. The Pigman of Northfield

• Originated: Northfield, Vermont, 1971

The Pigman of Northfield, a half-human, half-pig creature, allegedly roams the forests of Vermont, particularly around Devil’s Washbowl.

The legend began in 1971 when a local teenager disappeared, only to have sightings of a pig-faced figure crop up shortly after. Described as having the body of a man and the face of a pig, the Pigman is said to enjoy scaring the wits out of campers and hikers.

16. The Fresno Nightcrawlers

• Originated: Fresno, California, 2007

Not all urban legends come from the distant past. The Fresno Nightcrawlers, first caught on security cameras in 2007, look like walking pairs of pants with small heads.

The footage shows these strange creatures strolling eerily through a yard in Fresno. Unlike many urban legends, there’s actual video evidence of the Nightcrawlers, although skeptics argue it’s just a hoax.

Some say they’re aliens, while others think they’re spirits, but everyone agrees they’re downright weird.

MY FAVORITE TRAVEL RESOURCES

✈️ Find amazing guided tours and experiences with Viator to maximize your time! 🏘️ Plan ahead and secure your accommodation with Booking.com in advance. 🧾 Rent a car with Discovercars in advance and get the best prices for your day trip adventures.