10 States with the Biggest Sweet Tooth, According to DoorDash

day trip nomad affiliate disclosure

Another Halloween has come and gone, and with it, the initial beginnings of new cavities and a severe sugar overload we are all still trying to get past. But some states have a much bigger sweet tooth than others, according to data from food delivery service DoorDash.

From the most popular Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups to the hated Banana Laffy Taffy, DoorDash’s report found that Vermont has the biggest sweet tooth. The data is compiled by checking out which states ordered the most candy in the month leading up to and on Halloween.

1. Vermont

Vermont, Church in Burlington Square
Photo Credit: Deposit Photos.
  • Most Ordered Candy: Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups

Vermont may be known for maple syrup, but it turns out they’ve got a serious chocolate-and-peanut-butter obsession, too. The Green Mountain State combines a love of the outdoors with small-town charm, but don’t be surprised if the locals hand you a Reese’s instead of syrup.

Ski resorts and scenic drives bring people here year-round, and according to DoorDash’s data, they win the award for the most candy pit stops on those mountain trails.

2. South Dakota

South Dakota, Deadwood mainstreet, South Dakota
Photo Credit: peeterv // Canva.
  • Most Ordered Candy: Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups

South Dakota may be the home of Mount Rushmore, but apparently, they’d carve out some room for Reese’s if they could. This state is full of wide-open spaces, national parks, and a surprising number of peanut butter fans.

3. Nebraska

Downtown Omaha Nebraska Drone Photo
Photo Credit: Matt Bills // Canva.
  • Most Ordered Candy: Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups

In Nebraska, it’s all about agriculture, college football, and, evidently, another winner for Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups. The Cornhusker State might be corn country, but that doesn’t mean they don’t indulge in a few sweets now and then.

Known for its friendly communities and relaxed vibe, Nebraska also ranks high on the list for candy deliveries.

4. Iowa

Des Moines, Iowa Skyline
Photo Credit: paulbrady // Canva.
  • Most Ordered Candy: Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups

Iowa may be a leading corn producer, but it’s not candy corn, but peanut butter and chocolate that clearly gets the most love. Between the sprawling farms and cozy small towns, Reese’s has found a loyal fan base.

5. Arizona

Phoenix, Arizona, USA cityscape in downtown at sunset.
Photo Credit: Deposit Photos.
  • Most Ordered Candy: Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups

Arizona’s desert landscape may be hot, but that doesn’t stop residents from craving a sweet treat. From the Grand Canyon to lively urban spots, Reese’s has claimed its place among their top favorites.

6. Rhode Island

Rhode Island, Aerial panorama of Providence
Photo Credit: Deposit Photos.
  • Most Ordered Candy: Gusher’s Tropical

Rhode Island may be the smallest state, but its candy appetite is big, especially when it comes to fruity Gushers.

Among the coastal towns and seafood spots, Rhode Island has a unique flair for mixing flavors. Between beach days and boating, residents here have Gushers on the brain.

7. Kansas

View of Kansas City skyline in Missouri
Photo Credit: f11photo // Canva.
  • Most Ordered Candy: Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups

In Kansas, it’s another win for the Reese’s. The Sunflower State might be famed for its endless wheat fields, but the residents aren’t living alone on bread. With friendly people and a love for classic Americana, Kansas proves Reese’s is just as popular on the plains as anywhere else.

8. New Jersey

New Jersey, The skyline and Atlantic Ocean in Atlantic City
Photo Credit: Deposit Photos.
  • Most Ordered Candy: Gusher’s Tropical

New Jersey’s love for Gushers Tropical shows the Garden State has a taste for a little flair. From bustling boardwalks to densely packed suburbs, candy cravings are never far off here. As a native myself, I don’t disagree with the New Jersey favorite that keeps it fruity and fun, with Gushers leading the way in popularity.

9. Oklahoma

Tulsa, Oklahoma, USA Skyline
Photo Credit: Sean Pavone // Canva.
  • Most Ordered Candy: Chocolate Bar Assortment

Oklahoma likes to keep it classic with a whole assortment of chocolate bars. This is the classic mix of Hershey’s, Snickers, Twix, and more, where we hope the one that gets handed to us is the option that we actually like.

10. Wisconsin

Wisconsin, Milwaukee, USA downtown city skyline on Lake Michigan
Photo Credit: Deposit Photos.
  • Most Ordered Candy: Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups

In Wisconsin, Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups is another fan favorite. Between the rolling hills and the bustling cities, residents here have a clear taste for this beloved candy.

cat xu profile picture
 | Website

Catherine, a seasoned travel writer, has lived in 4 different states and explored 36 states and 28 national parks. After spending two years embracing van life, she's now dedicated to sharing her vast knowledge of day trips across America. Catherine's other works has been referenced in major publications like MSN, Self, and TripSavvy.

MY FAVORITE TRAVEL RESOURCES

✈️ Find amazing guided tours and experiences with Viator to maximize your time!

🏘️ Plan ahead and secure your accommodation with Booking.com in advance.

🧾 Rent a car with Discovercars in advance and get the best prices for your day trip adventures.